Skip to main content
Catskills Digital

Feature

What Breaks When You Refuse to Break

There are compromises that don't feel very important when we make them. Take the job for now. Put the project aside until things settle down. Stay where you are because moving would be expensive. Say yes because somebody is depending on you. Do the practical thing and come back to the other thing later. Often this is good advice. Adults have obligations,

The Mountain Eagle

There are compromises that don't feel very important when we make them.

Take the job for now. Put the project aside until things settle down. Stay where you are because moving would be expensive. Say yes because somebody is depending on you. Do the practical thing and come back to the other thing later.

Often this is good advice.

Adults have obligations, and obligations don't disappear merely because something else feels meaningful. Rent remains stubbornly interested in being paid. Children need things on schedules that don't necessarily correspond with our creative lives. Health insurance, aging parents, mortgages and ordinary exhaustion all get a vote.

I've also noticed that "for now" has an unusual ability to become ten years.

That's where the question gets harder.

There are people who eventually discover that a series of individually reasonable compromises has accumulated into a life they wouldn't have chosen all at once. Nothing terrible happened. There may have been promotions, a house, people they love and plenty of good days along the way.

Something still doesn't fit.

I don't think we should romanticize that feeling.

The fact that I feel misplaced doesn't prove that somewhere else is my authentic destiny. Dissatisfaction can come from circumstances, depression, boredom, comparison, unrealistic expectations or the ordinary fact that no life allows every possible version of us to be enacted at once.

Sometimes the problem really is the job.

Sometimes we're the problem.

Usually I'd want more evidence.

That's one reason I'm cautious with the language of calling. I've felt strongly drawn toward things that turned out to matter enormously, and I've also been extremely enthusiastic about things that disappeared from my attention six months later.

Both felt convincing while they were happening.

Time helps distinguish them.

So does work.

If something continues pulling at me after I've encountered its tedious parts, failed at it, learned what it actually requires and had opportunities to walk away, I begin taking the attraction more seriously.

Eventually a person may reach a point where continuing as they are has consequences too.

That's easy to overlook because staying usually presents itself as the absence of a decision.

It isn't.

Remaining in a job is a decision. Staying in a relationship is a decision. Continuing to organize your life around commitments made by an earlier version of yourself is a decision, even if nothing changes on Tuesday morning.

Sometimes stability is exactly what we need.

Sometimes stability has simply made its costs familiar.

Then something has to move.

This is where the phrase refusing to break becomes complicated, because I've seen at least two very different things hiding inside it.

One is the refusal to abandon something important merely because preserving it has become inconvenient.

The other is rigidity.

From inside, they can feel remarkably similar.

A person may stay committed to work nobody else understands and eventually produce something valuable. Another may spend twenty years pursuing an idea that isn't working because changing direction would require admitting how much has already been invested.

Persistence alone doesn't tell us which story we're in.

Neither does opposition.

If everyone around me thinks I'm making a mistake, perhaps I'm seeing something they aren't.

Perhaps they're seeing something I aren't.

That's inconvenient too.

The people who love us aren't neutral observers, but neither are we. They may be overly protective, attached to an older version of us or frightened by choices they wouldn't make themselves. They may also notice that we're becoming impossible to live with while explaining every consequence as the price of remaining true to ourselves.

Both happen.

A useful life has to leave room for that ambiguity.

I've become more interested in what happens when a person tries to preserve something important without requiring everything arou